注册 登录
滑铁卢中文论坛 返回首页

风萧萧的个人空间 https://www.kwcg.ca/bbs/?61910 [收藏] [复制] [分享] [RSS]

日志

全球应对大流行的策略陷入困境,专家提出蓝图

已有 5 次阅读2026-11-21 07:43 |个人分类:medicine

 全球应对大流行的策略陷入困境,专家提出旨在保护全体公民的蓝图

大流行防范 | 2026年9月21日 • Kerry Cullinan
https://healthpolicy-watch.news/as-global-pandemic-approach-flounders-experts-offer-blueprint-to-protect-all-citizens/

新冠疫情(COVID-19)结束至今不过三年,但许多世界领导人似乎对建立大流行防范机制缺乏兴趣。在联合国大流行问题高级别会议召开之际,一项涉及20个国家的大型研究项目提出了一份未来蓝图,有望挽救更多人的生命。

联合国将于本周五举行大流行问题高级别会议。然而,会议的政治宣言草案目前本就缺乏切实可行的执行方案,且随着美国极有可能在多边合作进程中设置障碍,这份草案的内容恐怕还会进一步被“缩减”。

上周五,世界卫生组织(WHO)《大流行协定》最后一项未决议题的谈判进入第八轮。作为该协定最坚定的推动者,世卫组织总干事谭德塞(Dr. Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus)承认,谈判进展“缓慢”。

就在三年多前,即2023年5月,新冠疫情带来的全球性创伤宣告终结——当时,官方统计的死亡人数已达700万,另有2800万“超额死亡”病例,且至少有7000万人因此陷入贫困。

然而,其他全球性危机似乎削弱了各国领导人为本国建立大流行防范机制的意愿。

不过,由新加坡国立大学(NUS)和《柳叶刀》(The Lancet)共同协调的一个全球专家团队,自2023年9月起便致力于深入分析新冠疫情期间出现的问题,并提出了一份蓝图,旨在帮助全球在未来应对此类危机时表现得更好。

PRIME委员会报告的核心结论指出,许多国家未能保护那些最需要保护的群体;它们所依赖的技术性方案,反而让数百万人暴露在感染风险之中。委员会指出:“在以下情况下,保护机制失效了:住房过度拥挤、工作缺乏保障、行政体系将部分群体拒之门外、不信任感阻碍了沟通,或者医疗与社会保障体系将风险转嫁给了家庭和社区。”

20个国家的案例研究
这项研究基于20个国家的案例研究,涵盖了从受疫情影响最严重的发达国家——美国,到莫桑比克等低收入国家的多种情况。

PRIME委员会联合主席海伦娜·莱吉多-奎格利(Helena Legido-Quigley)教授表示:“PRIME委员会的研究发现,人们本身并非‘脆弱’,而是各种体系制造了这种脆弱性。”

“住在拥挤公寓里的人无法进行社交隔离;没有身份证明文件的人无法获得政府发放的补助金;而不会说主流语言的人则无法理解相关的健康建议。”

在埃塞俄比亚、印度尼西亚、莫桑比克、坦桑尼亚和黎巴嫩,限制人员流动的封锁措施导致数百万人的基本生计来源断绝,许多家庭“在几天内就陷入了饥饿”。

一位在埃塞俄比亚流离失所的人员告诉研究人员:“我们早上吃一片面包,就得靠它撑过这一整天。”

在印度尼西亚,没有国民身份证号码的人无法接种疫苗。在秘鲁,家政工未能被纳入紧急现金援助计划的覆盖范围。在日本,一些老年居民则因不懂如何使用数字信息系统而面临困境。

报告指出:“美国体现了最深层的系统性排斥:移民身份、历史上针对特定劳动群体的排斥,以及强大的行业游说集团,共同阻碍了人们获取基本服务。联邦移民政策所引发的恐惧,使得劳动者不敢寻求基本的医疗护理。”

相比之下,那些拥有全民医疗保障和社会保护体系,且民众对公共机构抱有信任的国家——如新西兰、韩国、芬兰和不丹——表现得更好。

在国家保障体系中,老年人、外来务工人员、残障人士、原住民、非正规就业者,以及居住在偏远或公共服务匮乏地区的人群,往往是被忽视的群体。研究发现,在这20个国家中,呈现出了一些共同的模式。人们面临的风险之所以更高,是因为他们无法负担停止工作的代价、缺乏能够进行隔离的居住条件、无法获得政府支持、不信任所接收到的信息,或者所依赖的医疗及其他必要服务在巨大压力下已不堪重负。

促进公平,挽救更多生命
该委员会对未来的大流行情境进行了建模分析,对比了两种应对方式:一种是以权力和国家利益为导向,另一种则侧重于国际合作与公共卫生。

在假设的未来甲型流感大流行中,如果能迅速研发出疫苗,即便疫苗优先分配给那些支付能力最强的国家,也能使死亡人数减少59%(从5850万降至2390万)。

但如果疫苗分配是基于人口规模而非购买力,全球死亡人数则可减少64%,降至2120万。

若能采取措施提升人们对疫苗的信心,还将能额外挽救 190 万人的生命。

“针对流感大流行的模型研究结果明确表明,尽管维持现状也能挽救许多生命,但若能以更公平的方式分配疫苗,则可额外挽救数百万人的生命,”莱吉多-奎格利(Legido-Quigley)表示,“从道德层面而言,我们完全有理由建立一套机制,确保疫苗能够送达那些赖以生存的人手中,而非仅仅提供给那些买得起疫苗的人。”

2021 年 3 月,新冠疫苗终于抵达卢旺达。模型显示,如果疫苗分配是基于人口规模而非购买力,将能额外挽救数百万人的生命。

需要做出哪些改变?
该委员会制定了一份面向未来的蓝图,其核心由六大板块构成,首要任务便是保护民众与社区。

委员会指出,在应对大流行的准备工作中,目前缺失的是一种“切实可行且深刻的‘全社会参与’方略”;该方略应将社区、卫生系统、社会保障、金融、法律、教育、劳工、粮食系统、环境治理,以及区域和全球合作等各个领域紧密联结起来。

委员会强调,大流行“准备工作”的核心目标,应是确保民众与各类系统能够抵御大流行的冲击——这也为评估任何计划提供了一项切实可行的检验标准。

若要确保有效性,各项措施必须能够减少可避免的伤害,增强民众与社区的能力及福祉,惠及那些最缺乏服务保障的群体,并消除在获取保护与照护方面的结构性障碍。

在设计干预措施时,应让社区参与其中;同时,这些措施还必须具备应对虚假信息的能力。

“多年来,各国政府一直被建议在制定大流行应对规划时,应采取‘全社会参与’的方略,”大流行防范与应对独立小组(Independent Panel for Pandemic Preparedness and Response)联合主席海伦·克拉克(Helen Clark)表示。

“保护全体公民和居民是政府的职责所在。我们深知,新的大流行威胁随时可能出现。由新加坡国立大学(NUS)与《柳叶刀》(The Lancet)联合成立的 PRIME 委员会所提出的这份蓝图,绝不容忽视。”

As Global Pandemic Approach Flounders, Experts Offer Blueprint to Protect All Citizens


It's been barely three years since the COVID-19 pandemic ended, yet many world leaders appear to have little appetite for pandemic-proofing. Ahead of the UN High-Level Meeting on Pandemics, a major 20-country research project offers a blueprint for the future that could save millions more lives.

The United Nations hosts a High-Level Meeting on Pandemics on Friday, but the political declaration draft, currently thin on practical implementation plans, may be rendered even skinnier as the United States is almost certain to throw its spanner in the multilateral wheel.

At the end of the eighth round of talks to negotiate the last outstanding piece of the World Health Organization’s (WHO) Pandemic Agreement last Friday, WHO Director-General Dr Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus, its most ardent cheerleader, admitted that progress is “slow”.

Barely three years ago, in May 2023, the global trauma of the COVID-19 pandemic was declared to be at an end – after seven million official deaths, 28 million “excess deaths” and at least 70 million more people being thrust into poverty. 

Yet other global crises appear to have blunted world leaders’ appetite to pandemic-proof their countries.

However, a global team of experts, coordinated by the National University of Singapore (NUS) and The Lancet, has been hard at work since September 2023, working out what went wrong during COVID-19, and offering a blueprint to enable the world to perform better next time.

The overarching conclusion of the PRIME Commission report is that many countries failed to protect those who needed it most, relying on technical plans that left millions exposed to infection. 

“Protection failed in contexts where housing was overcrowded, work was insecure, administrative systems excluded people, distrust disrupted communication, or health and social systems shifted risk onto households and communities,” the commission notes.

Twenty-country case studies

The research rests on 20 country case studies, ranging from the United States, the worst affected developed country, to low-income countries such as Mozambique. 

“What the PRIME Commission found is that people themselves aren’t ‘vulnerable’, but rather that systems create vulnerability,” said Professor Helena Legido-Quigley, co-chair of PRIME Commission. 

“A person living in a crowded apartment cannot socially isolate, a person with no identity papers cannot access a government payment, and a person who doesn’t speak the dominant language cannot understand health advice.”

In Ethiopia, Indonesia, Mozambique, Tanzania, and Lebanon, lockdown regulations that restricted movement meant that the subsistence income of millions collapsed, with households “falling into hunger within days”. 

“We would survive the night after eating a piece of bread in the morning,” an internally displaced person in Ethiopia told researchers. 

In Indonesia, people without a national ID number could not get vaccines. In Peru, domestic workers were not covered by emergency cash transfers. Older Japanese residents did not know how to use digital information systems.

“USA represents the deepest form of systemic exclusion, where immigration status, historical labour exclusions, and powerful industry lobbies combine to block access to services. Fear generated by federal immigration policy prevented workers from seeking basic care,” the report notes.

In contrast, countries with universal health coverage, social protection, and there was trust in institutions, fared better – such as New Zealand, South Korea, Finland, and Bhutan. 

Groups commonly overlooked by national systems included older people, migrant workers, people with disabilities, indigenous peoples, informal workers, and people living in remote and underserved communities.

“Across the 20 countries, common patterns emerged. People could be put at greater risk because they could not afford to stop working, did not have housing that allowed them to isolate, could not access government support, did not trust the information they received, or depended on health and other essential services that struggled under pressure,” the research found.

More equity, more lives saved

The Commission modelled future pandemic scenarios, comparing a response driven by power and national interest with a response favouring international cooperation and public health. 

In a hypothetical future influenza A pandemic, if vaccines were developed rapidly, this could reduce deaths by 59% (from 58.5 million to 23.9 million), even when vaccines were distributed first to countries with the greatest ability to pay. 

But if vaccine allocation was based on population size rather than purchasing power, global mortality would be reduced by 64%, to 21·2 million deaths. Measures to improve vaccine confidence would reduce deaths by another 1.9 million lives. 

“The influenza pandemic modelling findings unequivocally show that while the status quo will protect many lives, a more equitable approach to vaccine distribution will save millions more,” said Legido-Quigley. “There is every moral justification to create a system where vaccines reach those who need them in order to live, and not only those who can afford them.”

COVID-19 vaccines finally arrived in Rwanda in March 2021. Modelling shows that millions more lives can be saved if vaccines are allocated according to population size rather than purchasing power.

What must change?

The Commission has developed a blueprint for the future based on six blocks, starting with protecting people and communities.

It argues that the missing element in pandemic readiness is a “practical and profound whole-of-society approach that connects communities, health systems, social protection, finance, law, education, labour, food systems, environmental governance, and regional and global cooperation”.

Pandemic “readiness” must be geared to ensuring that people and systems can withstand a pandemic, it argues, offering a practical test for any plan.

To be effective, any measure needs to reduce avoidable harm, strengthen the capabilities and wellbeing of people and communities, reach those most underserved and remove structural barriers to protection and care.

Communities should be involved in the design of the intervention, which must also be able to respond to misinformation.

“Governments have heard for years that they should take a ‘whole-of-society’ approach to pandemic planning,” said Helen Clark, co-chair of the Independent Panel for Pandemic Preparedness and Response. 

“It is a government’s responsibility to protect all of their citizens and residents. We know that a new pandemic threat could arise at any time. The NUS-Lancet PRIME Commission offers a blueprint that must not be ignored.” 


路过

鸡蛋

鲜花

握手

雷人

评论 (0 个评论)

facelist

您需要登录后才可以评论 登录 | 注册

法律申明|用户条约|隐私声明|小黑屋|联系我们|www.kwcg.ca

GMT-5, 2026-11-22 01:30 , Processed in 0.009311 second(s), 19 queries , Gzip On.

Powered by Discuz! X5.0

© 2001-2021 Comsenz Inc.  

返回顶部