注册 登录
滑铁卢中文论坛 返回首页

风萧萧的个人空间 https://www.kwcg.ca/bbs/?61910 [收藏] [复制] [分享] [RSS]

日志

Martin Wolf 历史能否有助于预测美国未来两年的政治走向

已有 14 次阅读2026-11-21 14:40 |个人分类:政治 法律

 历史能否有助于预测美国未来两年的政治走向?——马丁·沃尔夫(Martin Wolf)谈美国中期选举

《金融时报》(Financial Times),2026年11月21日
Could history help predict the next two years of US politics? | Martin Wolf on the US midterms

Financial Times 2026年11月21日
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XI5HoAj7ELM

民主党在中期选举中大获全胜,而唐纳德·特朗普(Donald Trump)依然担任总统。未来两年局势会如何发展?历史又能为我们揭示些什么?马丁·沃尔夫采访了历史学家希瑟·考克斯·理查森(Heather Cox Richardson),探讨了过去250年美国政治中的周期性规律——即在寡头统治时期之后,社会如何走向复兴(或陷入分裂);同时,民主党又该如何应对当前的“宪政危机”。

主持人:马丁·沃尔夫(Martin Wolf)
希瑟·考克斯·理查森(Heather Cox Richardson,1962年生)是一位美国历史学家、作家,现任波士顿学院(Boston College)历史学教授。她的研究专长包括美国内战、重建时期、美国西部史以及平原印第安人历史。

著作:她的代表作包括《民主的觉醒:关于美国现状的笔记》(Democracy Awakening: Notes on the State of America)、《南方如何赢得内战:寡头政治、民主与美国灵魂的持续争夺》(How the South Won the Civil War: Oligarchy, Democracy, and the Continuing Fight for the Soul of America,2020年出版)、《让人们获得自由:共和党史》(To Make Men Free: A History of the Republican Party)、《从阿波马托克斯向西》(West from Appomattox),以及《伤膝河:政党政治与通往美国大屠杀之路》(Wounded Knee: Party Politics and the Road to an American Massacre)。[1, 2]

我们正处于一场宪政危机之中,而我们无法与那些制造这场危机的人“和睦相处”。这就像是要求消防员与纵火犯和平共处一样——根本行不通。
我是马丁·沃尔夫,《金融时报》首席经济评论员。
美国选民让唐纳德·特朗普领导的共和党遭遇了惨败。民主党目前已掌控了众议院和参议院,但特朗普在白宫的任期还剩下两年。民主党能在多大程度上对他形成制约?这场选举是否已经改变了美国民主的进程? 0:41 在美国中期选举中,民主党取得了重大胜利;选民们以这种方式,对特朗普总统及共和党表达了强烈的否定。
0:49 那么,这场“压倒性胜利”究竟有多罕见?从长远来看,它又具有怎样的重要意义呢?
0:58 在本系列探讨中期选举的最后一期播客中,我邀请了一位嘉宾,她将帮助我从更宏观的视角——即美国250年政治史的跨度——来审视此次选举。
1:13 希瑟·考克斯·理查森(Heather Cox Richardson)是波士顿学院的历史学教授,也是广受欢迎的Substack时事通讯《来自美国人的信》(Letters from an American)的作者。
1:22 她对美国历史上塑造了国家面貌的种种政治博弈——从南北战争一直延续至今——有着深入的研究。希瑟,欢迎来到节目。
1:34 很高兴能参加节目。希瑟,在中期选举结束后的第二天,你曾写道:美国政治的一个时代正在终结,而另一个时代即将开启。你这话是什么意思呢?
1:46 我认为,中期选举对“MAGA共和党主义”(MAGA Republicanism)的裁决,其内涵远不止针对特朗普个人或“MAGA共和党人”那么简单。
1:54 这实际上是对共和党自20世纪80年代以来所秉持的经济愿景的一种彻底否定。
2:04 我之所以这么说,不仅是因为共和党人在一些关键选民群体中遭遇了惨败,
2:13 还因为此次选举所涉及的诸多议题,并不仅仅局限于特朗普政府时期的腐败问题。尽管这在不同的人群中似乎都是首要关切的问题,但如果你审视那些转而反对特朗普的人——无论他们身处何地,包括在农村地区——你会发现,他们所关注的是那些真正重大、足以改变美国政治本质的问题。在那场选举中,一个关键议题就是“数据中心”。在我看来,这些数据中心象征着人们的一种觉醒:即美国的政治和经济体系长期以来一直受到操纵,偏袒极度富有的阶层。
美国民众已经意识到了这一点。当这种情况发生时——正如历史上20世纪20至30年代、19世纪90年代以及19世纪50年代所经历的那样——美国政治往往会发生剧烈的变革。这就是我当时所指的意思。
所以,你实际上是在描述一个重大的转折点。你曾将美国政治史形容为一场斗争,一场民主与寡头统治之间长期的较量。你能否进一步阐释一下你的这一观点?虽然你刚才已经有所提及,但能否具体说明一下,在过去250年里,这种较量是如何演变的?以及为什么你认为我们可能正处于一个新周期的开端——或许可以称之为“进步周期”?我们往往会经历这样一些时期:在这些时期里,大多数选民意识到体制遭到了操纵——正如我刚才所言,这种操纵方式通常旨在优待男性,尤其是那些既富有又有权势的白人男性;他们与政府密切勾结,共同扭曲整个体制,使其向自身倾斜。每当这种情况发生,往往会引发一场反抗,进而改变我们的政治体制;随之而来的是一系列旨在……的立法。一个更公平的经济体系,让繁荣的机会能够比过去(在旧体制下)更广泛地惠及民众。然而,由于我们独特的历史——我所说的“独特”不仅是指“奇怪”,而是指美国体制中某种非常特殊的现象——那些想要聚敛财富的人,往往会反过来指责那个致力于服务全体美国民众的政府,声称这是一种“社会主义”体制。他们宣称,这种服务于全体美国人(而非仅仅服务于少数特权阶层)的政府,实际上是在将富人的税款重新分配给那些“不配”得到这些资源的人群——比如少数族裔、女性,或是其他任何被归类为“他者”的群体。通过这种手段,他们往往能成功地在选民中制造分裂,并借此再次攫取权力。随后,通常会发生剧烈的经济崩溃,整个循环又重新开始。这种模式贯穿了我们的历史,至少从19世纪50年代、90年代,一直到20世纪30年代,都反复出现。但如果我们回溯一下美国宪法制定者和美国国家奠基人的初衷,就会发现,他们始终担忧的一点是:任何旨在治理民众的体制,往往都会倾向于将权力集中在极少数人手中。如果仔细思考一下他们​​当初的构想,以及他们在体制内所设置的“制衡”机制——旨在防止此类情况发生——那么或许可以说,美国民主的真谛,就在于努力防止财富与权力在政府中过度集中。
让我们回顾一下历史上经历过的一些重大转折。您曾特别提到过19世纪50年代,据我理解,那段时期不仅见证了共和党的诞生,也是南北战争的前奏;当然,它还造就了全球民主史上的一位伟大英雄——亚伯拉罕·林肯,他不仅属于美国民主,更属于世界民主。能否请您谈谈那个“重生”或“诞生”的时刻?当时一种更具民主色彩、更具包容性的理念应运而生——尽管最终引发了一场围绕奴隶制展开的战争。您认为这段历史对于我们当下的处境有何启示?
我之所以对19世纪50年代情有独钟,原因有几点;其中蕴含的一种政治模式,在当下这个时刻,令我深感共鸣。当时,两大老牌政党都刻意回避了一个显而易见却又被避而不谈的重大问题——即北方人所称的“奴隶主势力”(slave power)的崛起。所谓“奴隶主势力”,指的是那些掌控了民主党的南方奴隶主精英阶层。他们不仅掌控了民主党,还把持了最高法院、参议院和总统职位——这听起来是不是有点耳熟?如果你是
1854年的一位北方人,看到这些情况,你可能会说:“我根本不在乎。我主要关心的是
搬到城市里,或者向西部发展。现在经济正处于繁荣期,我更关心自己的切身利益,而不是
华盛顿那边发生了什么。这与我无关。”而且,我确实不必关心,因为我们掌握着众议院。在这个国家,我们的人数占绝大多数。我们控制着
众议院,而那些南方的奴隶主精英阶层,其人口占比还不到1%。所以,他们又能坏到哪儿去呢?情况又能糟糕到什么地步呢?
到了1854年,众议院议员们开始承受来自总统(尤其是总统)以及参议院的压力,
被迫通过了一项名为《堪萨斯-内布拉斯加法案》(Kansas-Nebraska Act)的法律。该法案推翻了1820年的《密苏里妥协案》(Missouri Compromise)——
根据该妥协案,奴隶制不得向西扩张至那里的广大领土。随着《密苏里妥协案》被推翻,
如果奴隶主将他们的“奴隶财产”带入这些西部领土,那么这些领土未来就可能变成实行奴隶制的西部州。这些西部州将与南部的蓄奴州联手,试图在全国范围内推行奴隶制——这直接威胁到了居住在北部的绝大多数美国人——并最终将整个国家变成一个蓄奴国。就在此事发生后的第二天,约30名国会议员在华盛顿举行了一次会议。他们在会上对彼此说道:“听着,我们在国内基础设施建设、财政融资以及移民问题上或许存在分歧,但有一点我们绝对能达成共识:我们绝不能让我们的民主制度落入‘奴隶主势力’(slave power)的掌控之中。”此后,在1854、1855和1856年间,那些反对《内布拉斯加法案》的人士在美国北部各州的选举中。
他们进入了国会,也掌握了各州的权力,并开始探讨美国民主应有的样貌。
在19世纪50年代,随着“奴隶制势力”不断巩固其地位——例如,他们甚至在参议院大厅内,将一位来自马萨诸塞州的参议员打得奄奄一息——在伊利诺伊州,亚伯拉罕·林肯开始崭露头角。他倾听各方声音,
不仅明确表达了反对奴役人类的立场,还提出了一种关于美国民主应有样貌的新愿景:即“民有、民治、民享”的民主。
他开始倡导一系列主张,旨在让普通民众——普通人——能够获得财产、通过辛勤工作实现向上流动。这后来成为了共和党的核心意识形态。
因此,当我们审视当下的混乱局面时——比如那些走向极端的“MAGA共和党人”(“让美国再次伟大”派共和党人),他们正如同跳下悬崖般走向毁灭,这本身就耐人寻味——而其他人
则留在悬崖之上,茫然地表示:“我们其实并不清楚自己究竟主张什么。我们唯一确定的是,我们不支持……”
这让我联想到19世纪50年代的情景,当时人们也在探讨:21世纪的民主究竟该是什么样子?
我们该做些什么?政府又该做些什么?政府有哪些义务与职责?我认为,这些探讨确实与19世纪50年代的那个时期有着惊人的相似之处。 10:30 这是一个非常有趣的类比。
10:32 让我们谈谈在取得这一显著成果之后,我们当下的处境;并深入探讨一下你的观点——即这标志着一场根本性的变革。
10:42 有没有可能,这实际上是对特朗普及其政策的一种反弹?
10:49 毕竟那些政策如此恶劣——充斥着腐败和残暴行径。这难道不是对共和党过去约60年来整体政治议程更深层次的否定吗?你倾向于认为是后者,能解释一下原因吗?
11:05 当然可以。我预言的是过去,而非未来。一切皆有可能,对吧?明天这一切也可能瞬间化为乌有。
11:12 但基于多方面原因,我并不认为情况会是那样。首先,我们讨论得不够充分的一点是,美国目前正经历着巨大的人口结构变化——“婴儿潮”一代(我也是其中一员)正在淡出,新一代人正在崛起。
11:27 值得注意的是,德克萨斯州之所以出现如此剧烈的“由红转蓝”的转变,一个关键因素在于,从人口结构来看,德克萨斯州是全美最年轻的州之一。
11:34 这种人口结构的变化,我认为至关重要。而且显而易见,这种趋势不会轻易改变。此外,你刚才列举的特朗普政府治下所发生的一系列现象,其实并非特朗普政府所独有。这些现象在特朗普政府时期或许有所加剧,但绝非仅见于此。比如减税、削减社会服务等举措,其源头可以追溯到1981年——正如我们之前讨论过的,那是罗纳德·里根(Ronald Reagan)崛起、新自由主义或供给侧经济学思想开始渗透进体制的时期。特别是在过去两年里,我们看到不少经济学家开始向公众普及这些概念,也有许多政客频繁谈论亿万富翁如何攫取了社会财富。而埃隆·马斯克(Elon Musk)的出现——尤其是在“特朗普2.0”时代——让这一问题显得格外突出。可以说,马斯克简直就是那种“为非作歹的资本大亨”(robber baron)的典型代表。再加上如雨后春笋般涌现的数据中心——这些设施在两党阵营中都同样遭人厌恶——这一切都象征着我们对公共空间的掌控权正在丧失。我认为,人们当下的不满绝不仅仅是因为鸡蛋价格太高,而是因为大家已经意识到:这套体制必须做出改变。看看人们发出的呼声,你会发现,他们确实对特朗普感到愤怒,但这种愤怒并非仅仅针对特朗普。他们诉求的是医疗保障——在2026年,这算不上什么激进的想法,尤其是考虑到我们是世界上极少数缺乏此类保障体系的国家之一。他们还希望获得体面的薪资,即每周工作40小时便足以支付房租。人们所追求的,并非某种“变体”的自由民主,而是自由民主制度的回归。我认为,这种已经释放出来的力量,恐怕再也无法被收回了。我真正担心的是另一种情况:随着“让美国再次伟大”(MAGA)运动变本加厉——正如我们眼下所见的那样——最终可能会导致情况恰恰相反。有些人会说:“算了吧,我们根本不需要自由民主制,我们愿意尝试点别的。”我认为这种情况……
……让人联想到1933年富兰克林·罗斯福(FDR)所处的境况。这是一个非常重要的问题,也与我近年来所担忧的一点相契合——即我们有可能彻底失去民主制度。不过……
……在此之前,民主党人突然发现自己在国会中占据了极其强大的地位。
他们可以在很大程度上阐述一种新的执政理念——尽管我认为他们迄今为止尚未真正做到这一点。
在我看来,目前的局面相当令人困惑。那么,你认为民主党人该做些什么?他们又该如何行动,才能巩固……
……这个在某些方面显然存在分歧的新选举联盟呢?
首先要说明的是,我认为这种“困惑”在当下其实是一件好事。
常有人问我:“你支持2028年大选中的哪位候选人?现在谁处于领先地位?为什么大家都不表态?”对此,我的回答……
……可以追溯到19世纪50年代。回看亚伯拉罕·林肯的崛起,你会发现,当时还有大约10个人也在倡导一种全新的……
……政治模式。他成功地汲取了那些事物中最精华的部分——即便未必是“最好”的,至少也是那些经久不衰、
15:08 能够得到大多数北方人支持的内容。我认为我们现在看到的正是同样的情况。只要你足够留心,就能观察到这一点。你可以看到
15:15 一些民主党领导人,或是那些非“MAGA派”(即非特朗普铁杆支持者阵营)的共和党人,开始抛出一些“试探性言论”;
15:23 你会发现一些新面孔提出新的观点——如果反响不佳,他们就会退缩;如果反响尚可,他们则会顺势进一步推进,
15:32 或是向其他方向调整。观察这种政治博弈的过程,其实非常有意思。所以,这倒不必让我担心。我认为,民主党接下来需要做的事,其实并不复杂,对吧?
15:42 他们目前并未掌控白宫。而那位掌控白宫的人,其行事风格——往好听了说——也是出了名的反复无常。
15:49 我们这些密切关注他的人,并不认为他在精神或身体上处于健康状态。而且,究竟是谁在白宫里真正说了算,也并不明确。
15:58 但可以肯定的是,这些决策不仅极具争议,甚至可能涉嫌违法,
16:07 以至于白宫现在正拼命掩盖痕迹,试图阻挠任何调查。这可不是什么好兆头,
16:14 预示着未来两年恐怕不会太太平。话虽如此,国会还是必须采取一些行动,比如——调查那些违法行为。顺便提一下,这些调查不仅旨在恢复法治,还在于让美国民众了解在他们(当政者)的任期内究竟发生了什么,
哪些行为合法,以及哪些方面需要做出改变。这实际上关乎民主。
这不仅仅是指出在加勒比海或东太平洋轰炸小型船只的行为有多么离谱——
虽然这确实是问题的核心,但事情远不止于此。
它还涉及与之相关的一切。因此,他们必须开展这些调查。此外,我认为他们还需要针对具体的立法议题采取行动,而不是依赖那种庞大的
“综合法案”——即把所有乱七八糟的内容一股脑塞进一份长达2600页的法案里,仅仅因为只有这样它才有可能在国会获得通过。
他们应当将那些广受支持的议题拆分为独立的、小型的法案——比如延长“补充营养援助计划”(SNAP)的福利,
从而让人们能够……怎么说呢,解决具体的生活需求,并切实地改善他们的日常生活。
当然,特朗普,或者如果JD·万斯(JD Vance)入主白宫,他们完全可能会否决这些法案。但明确区分
哪些主张是广受民众欢迎的——我刚才提到的这些立场并非边缘观点,而是
美国民众真正想要的——与“MAGA派”共和党人所提出的方案之间的差异,对于未来的局势至关重要。而且,白宫不仅在坚持推行美国民众刚刚明确拒绝的政策,甚至还在进一步加大力度。比如,白宫撤换了幕僚长苏西·怀尔兹(Susie Wiles),转而起用斯蒂芬·米勒(Steven Miller)——他正是那些被美国民众彻底否决的驱逐计划的策划者。这一举动反而让民主党的工作变得轻松多了;因为如果白宫选择缓和立场,他们或许还能对外宣称:“听着,我们确实听取了你们的意见,也正在落实你们的诉求。”但事实上,白宫却采取了截然相反的立场。因此,我预计接下来各方将更加聚焦于美国民众的真实诉求接下来的两年……但请务必明确一点,这段时期将会异常艰难、充满波折,因为特朗普现在已陷入了被动境地。
他在外交政策领域反而拥有了最大的行动自由。未来几年注定会动荡不安。
这一点显而易见。我们看到唐纳德·特朗普与弗拉基米尔·普京以及习近平表现得十分亲昵——
这在不久前,人们恐怕还无法想象一位美国总统会做出这样的举动。因此,我们无疑正目睹一个在外交关系上令人感到极度不安的局面的开端。
你之前提到,民主党应该行使他们的调查权;正如你所言,这显然会引发他们与白宫之间的严重摩擦,
局面恐怕会变得相当棘手。此外,还有一个领域极有可能爆发重大冲突——我想知道你是否考虑过预算问题?
国会明确掌握着预算权,这是否意味着可能会再次出现债务上限危机,
甚至导致政府停摆?这些都是国会——也就是民主党——手中掌握的切实工具。
你认为民主党会——或者说,在你看来,他们应该——在多大程度上利用这些手段来贯彻自己的意志?
毕竟在这些领域,他们原则上确实拥有巨大的权力。
那么,需要明确的是,这是两件不同的事情。当然,今年的预算将于12月11日到期,届时共和党仍同时掌控着众议院和参议院。我估计,国会将维持政府现有的拨款水平,这实际上相当于按下了“暂停键”(或“稍后再提醒”),将问题推给了新一届国会。况且,许多在选举中落败的人甚至连华盛顿都不来了,这在我看来简直令人匪夷所思。再谈谈共和党拨给“海关与边境保护局”(CBP)——即边境巡逻队的上级机构——的那笔巨额资金;正是这些边境巡逻人员在街头采取了诸如向亚历克斯·普雷(Alex Prey)开枪之类的行动。此外,还有拨给“移民与海关执法局”(ICE)的资金。如果这些巨额拨款最终没有以某种方式被收回,我会感到非常震惊,因为这些资金实际上是在支撑这些机构运作,直至特朗普任期结束——这就是他们获得如此巨额拨款的原因。当然,这些举措极不受欢迎;在11月的选举中,选民们明确表示他们并不认同这些做法。不过,还有一个债务上限的问题,我很想听听你对此有何看法。这是一套奇怪的机制,实际上源于第一次世界大战时期。一些民主党人曾提出——特朗普也表示他赞同,尽管两者的出发点截然不同——干脆彻底废除债务上限。
但这并不能解决债务问题;目前的债务总额已超过40万亿美元,且仍在不断攀升。因此,我不知道最终会如何演变,但我可以肯定,这绝不仅仅是一个政治问题。
这对美国经济、美国政府,甚至可以说对全球经济而言,都是一场关乎存亡的危机。而它竟然沦为了政治博弈的筹码,这让我感到非常震惊。你对此怎么看?嗯,这绝对是个极其愚蠢的想法。
我曾多次撰文讨论过这个问题。既然它确实存在——据我了解,我也一直在关注——
那么,债务上限很可能会在下一个财政年度内触及。届时,它就成了一种筹码。
当然,和这类事情一样,它也可能产生反噬,甚至导致局面彻底失控。
这是民主党人必须面对的问题之一,因为他们有能力在原则上对现任政府施加相当大的制约。
其中一些制约措施可能会极其危险,引发严重的危机。而这正是最显而易见的一个。这里核心的问题是:在当前形势下,民主党人采取强硬手段对抗政府,究竟在多大程度上是合理的?毕竟,可供他们采取强硬立场的议题确实不少。
此外,考虑到整体政治背景,寻求某种既能解决问题、又不至于彻底“炸锅”的方案,又有多大意义呢?毕竟,政府在某些关键领域掌握着相当大的权力,这使得相关决策变得异常棘手。
我想先说明一点:我只是个“旁观者”(坐在“廉价席位”上的人)。
比如坐在笔记本电脑前,指点江山——说“他们应该这样做,不该那样做”——实在太容易了。我时刻意识到这一点,因此也愿意对那些身处决策一线的人多一份宽容。话虽如此,令我担忧的是,政府中仍有不少留任人员,他们似乎认为一切照旧,一切如常。而“特朗普2.0”政府的一个独特之处在于,他们的所作所为不仅是非法和违宪的;
他们行事简直就像宪法根本不存在一样。他们无视法院的权威,也不顾宪法所设定的制衡机制,诸如此类。因此,撇开政治影响不谈——当然,我认为这些政治影响至关重要——民主党人必须意识到,我们正处于一场宪法危机之中。事实上,从特朗普上台、拒绝承认国会拨款权的那一天起,我们就已经陷入了这场危机。既然身处宪法危机之中,我们就绝不能与那些制造危机的人“和睦相处”。这就像是让消防员与纵火犯和平共处一样,根本行不通。此外,我还想补充一点:这背后有着政治上的迫切需求——如今全国上下的民意已经发生转变,人们渴望的是“斗士”。回望历史,19世纪50年代和90年代的情况也是如此。 24:37 这就是为什么我们会看到像19世纪90年代西奥多·罗斯福(Teddy Roosevelt)那样的人物出现。人们需要的是那种敢于站出来对抗“科技权贵”(tech bros)的人——也就是那些
24:45 在国内垄断了财富与权力的人。顺便提一下,眼下这些“科技权贵”正拼命与“让美国再次伟大”(MAGA)运动划清界限,这本身就很有意思。
24:55 总之,确实存在一种“我们要抗争”的迫切诉求。此外,我认为还有一点,
25:04 在大量讨论民主党内部“建制派”与“进步派”分裂的文章中,这一点往往被掩盖了。
25:12 事实上,如果你仔细审视民主党人所呼吁的各项诉求,你会发现,
25:19 他们想要实现的目标,其实就是我常说的“唾手可得的成果”(low-hanging fruit)。比如,就拿“全民医保”来说,
25:26 连共和党人也支持这一点——有57%的共和党人表示赞同。
25:33 因此,许多人眼中的“极端”举措,实际上却是广受欢迎的。
25:41 所以,我的观点是:民主党人应当在各项议题上全力以赴,放手一搏。话虽如此,他们所受到的批评之一——其中一些人,包括密歇根州候任参议员阿卜杜勒·埃尔-赛义德(Abdul El-Sayed),曾提出:何不推行全民医保,并将其命名为“特朗普医保”(Trumpcare)呢?对此,一些人——尤其是那些政治立场更偏左的人——质问道:你们怎么敢与他合作?但我个人认为,这其实非常高明:把方案摆在特朗普的办公桌上,告诉他“你可以成为英雄”,而且这上面还会冠以你的名字。说实话,我不在乎它叫什么,我只希望它能真正实现。这种策略很可能会被更多人采用,尤其是那些政治敏锐度高的人——比如纽约市长埃里克·亚当斯(Eric Adams)——他此前就曾通过与特朗普合作,达成了自己的目标。我认为,利用某种“掩护”来推动激进变革,不失为一种好办法。
如果民主党人能做到这一点,并转型为一个类似于欧洲“社会民主党”的政党,那完全没问题。从很多方面来看,两者其实如出一辙。他们必须主张提高税收,并挑战共和党的一项核心原则——即“无论在任何情况下都绝不能加税”。但大家不妨看看,与同类国家相比,美国的税收水平处于什么位置?再看看美国历史上的税收水平又是如何?我们正处于一个历史最低点,财富正高度集中在社会顶层。人们对此也愈发察觉。我一直强调的一个观点是——大家知道吗,正是那个政党引入了美国的所得税制度。
虽然其他国家也曾采用过类似的税制,但在美国,引入所得税——而且从一开始就是累进所得税——的政党,正是共和党。那时的共和党与现在大不相同。
确实,现在的共和党已经不同以往;但共和党——就像美国政府本身一样——历经了多次演变,进入一个全新的阶段也并非不可想象。举个例子,大家不妨想想20世纪20年代,在美国财政部长安德鲁·梅隆(Andrew Mellon)任内,他向民众提供了大量的税收减免,实际上削弱了第一次世界大战后所倡导的“累进税制”理念。然而,仅仅二三十年后,在一位共和党总统——德怀特·艾森豪威尔(Dwight Eisenhower)——的领导下,我们却迎来了所得税率的最高水平,最高档次的所得税率达到了91%至92%。因此,这并非不可能,而且我认为,这绝对是当务之急。
接下来我想问您最后三个问题。希望您的回答能精炼有力,因为这些问题本身就需要这样的回答。第一个问题是:这是“让美国再次伟大”(MAGA)运动的终结吗?鉴于我们刚刚目睹了这种“否定”态势,您所提到的共和党转型是否已成必然——即这种转型是否一定会发生?
这并非“MAGA运动”的终结,因为这类群体将始终存在于美国社会之中。但这确实标志着“MAGA运动”作为共和党内部驱动力的终结。共和党——就像民主党一样——将不得不进行自我重塑。
这是一个非常有力的回答。那么,这些选举结果对于美国“寡头政治”的未来意味着什么?这仅仅是一场无休止的博弈,而寡头们在过去几年里是否因为“用力过猛”而遭遇了挫折?还是说,您认为这实际上可能带来某种长期的、根本性的变革? 29:24 这可不是三言两语就能回答的问题。确实不是。我完全同意这一点。
29:30 我认为,未来会发生什么,我们尚不得而知。那些拥有巨额财富的人,依然坐拥巨额财富,并且在美国依然施加着非同寻常的
29:40 影响力。不过,显然已经出现了一种旨在约束他们的政治动向,这种约束终有一天会实现。
29:47 但问题在于,这究竟会发生在未来3年内,还是未来30年内,亦或是未来
29:54 300年内?最后一个问题:我们重点关注美国是理所应当的,因为它是世界上最重要的国家,
30:03 尤其是对于那些认同西方自由主义价值观的人而言。显然,美国近期的所作所为
30:11 令人极其震惊。我之前提到的所谓“雅尔塔2.0”会晤,在多个层面
30:20 上都造成了巨大的冲击。美国一方面从世界舞台上“撤退”,另一方面又以极其反复无常、难以预测的方式
30:29 介入全球事务;而且,它似乎始终在支持——至少是支持了其中一些——暴君。你认为这种状况
30:38 在未来两年乃至更长的时间里还会持续下去吗?还是说,我们有可能重回过去那种局面——即美国
30:47 再次成为世界舞台上发挥稳定作用的霸权国家?那曾是我们习以为常的,也是我们当中许多人非常、非常怀念的状态。显而易见,特朗普采纳了弗拉基米尔·普京的观点,即主张将世界划分为不同的势力范围。我认为,这在很大程度上也是你所提到的、将于2026年11月中旬举行的那场三方会晤背后的动因。
但需要注意的是,弗拉基米尔·普京其实很虚弱。尽管他竭力表现得仿佛自己是主宰世界的“君王”之一,但眼下的他其实非常虚弱。他的国家经济陷入了困境,在乌克兰的战局也已对他不利。
目前真正支撑着他的,正是唐纳德·特朗普。我不认为特朗普的行事风格是反复无常的;相反,他的行动逻辑在于:美国应当掌控整个西半球。国务卿马可·卢比奥显然也完全赞同这一立场——他盯上了古巴;此外,还有针对委内瑞拉的干预行动,旨在攫取那里的石油资源。关键在于,特朗普始终意图掌控全球的化石燃料资源,这似乎正是他进行各类对外干预背后的核心动机。
那么,这种情况会持续下去吗?我认为,从短期来看,得益于美国宪法的相关条文,特朗普在外交事务上拥有比其他领域更大的回旋余地。当然,这并非绝对——纵观美国历史,宪法也并非一直被如此解读。此外,现任最高法院也多次指出,总统在外交事务上拥有一定的自由裁量权。这正是他将许多国内立法举措——例如针对从南部边境入境人员的驱逐行动——归类为“外交事务”范畴的原因之一。
因此,我认为他不仅不会收手,反而会采取更多此类行动。但关键在于,国会是否会为这些举措提供资金支持?
毕竟,军方目前在弹药储备和经费方面都面临着困境。那么,参议员们会这背后的意图是什么?他们会——
比如,他们会停止针对伊朗的战争吗?因此,我认为在未来两年内,美国不太可能突然改变特朗普所设定的方针;但这种局面恐怕也持续不了多久。老实说,眼下最让我感兴趣的一点是:看看特朗普所做的一切,以及考虑到基于规则的国际秩序因种种原因而逐渐瓦解的现状——我至今还没看到有什么真正能取代它的东西。在前总统乔·拜登及其国务卿安东尼·布林肯执政期间,曾出现过一种——姑且这么称呼吧——“临时委员会”式的构想:即由不同国家聚在一起,针对特定议题(例如芬太尼危机、边境管控,或其他各方共同关心的议题)进行磋商。这种模式在很大程度上借鉴了欧盟的做法。然而,这一理论框架中始终缺失了一环:当出现像普京、特朗普或内塔尼亚胡这类“不按常理出牌”的领导人时,该怎么办?如何才能促使这些人以一种“合乎规范”的方式行事,从而让各国能够开展合作呢?
因此,我认为目前出现的情况——比如来自加拿大的马克·卡尼(Mark Carney)所提出的构想——与上述模式有相似之处,但关键区别在于:布林肯和拜登曾默认,美国会参与到所有这些磋商机制之中。 34:15 他们之所以一直坚持美国既是太平洋大国,也是大西洋大国,原因之一在于,这实际上使美国能够参与到各类国际事务的讨论桌前。像卡尼(Carney)这类人则认为,
34:24 我们不需要那些“大块头”国家。我们可以由一群中等国家来主导——这听起来是个不错的想法,但它同样面临一个问题:你该如何约束那些拒绝……
34:32 承认——比如——联合国宪章中关于“不得入侵邻国”这一宗旨的国家呢?因此,在我看来,无论从思想层面还是从……
34:40 我们未来的角度来看,外交事务的发展才是核心议题,而非次要问题;这是21世纪……
34:48 必须面对的关键问题。我完全同意这一点。这也让我们回到了整个系列讨论的核心前提:美国所上演的这场“心理剧”——如果可以这么称呼的话——这场政治大戏,具有深远的全球意义。
35:05 虽然当前正处于一个关键时刻,但相关疑问依然存在。希瑟·考克斯·理查森(Heather Cox Richardson),非常感谢您今天接受我们的采访。
35:13 谢谢你们的邀请。
35:14 至此,我们关于美国政治现状及其与全球政治关联(特别是在中期选举期间)的系列讨论就全部结束了。
35:26 中期选举的结果相当令人震惊。
35:33 这实际上是对特朗普政府、共和党以及“让美国再次伟大”(MAGA)运动的一次远超预期的、更为彻底的否定。
35:42 这显然是非常令人振奋的。但这确实留下了一些关于未来的重大疑问。首先,这种“分裂的政府”——而且在美国,这种分裂程度将会非常严重——究竟该如何运作?它实际上将如何发挥作用?特朗普政府本身又会如何应对已经发生的一切?他们是否会采取更大的冒险行动,特别是在国际舞台上?这又会呈现出怎样的局面?那些遭受严重损害的各类体制,能否实现自我修复,
从而重现美国宪政体系的活力——毕竟这一体系此前已明显遭到了冲击。此外,还有这些情况对整个世界所带来的影响。
我们曾长期依赖美国。它一直是核心霸权力量,尤其是在自由民主国家阵营中。然而,它并未能明确地发挥这一角色;事实上,唐纳德·特朗普甚至否定了这一角色。那么,这一角色能否得到恢复?人们曾经对美国的信任,又能否失而复得?这些问题依然悬而未决。
我们经历了一段关键时期,但故事显然远未结束。

Could history help predict the next two years of US politics? | Martin Wolf on the US midterms

Financial Times 2026年11月21日
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XI5HoAj7ELM

The Democrats swept the midterms. Donald Trump is still president. What will the next two years look like? And what can history teach us about what comes next? Martin Wolf speaks to historian Heather Cox Richardson about the cycles in the past 250 years of US politics — how renewal (and division) can both follow periods of oligarchy, and how the Democrats should react to a “constitutional crisis”.

Host: Martin Wolf
Heather Cox Richardson (born 1962) is an American historian, author, and history professor at Boston College specializing in the Civil War, Reconstruction, the American West, and the Plains Indians.

Books: Her notable works include Democracy Awakening: Notes on the State of America, How the South Won the Civil War: Oligarchy, Democracy, and the Continuing Fight for the Soul of America (2020), To Make Men Free: A History of the Republican Party, West from Appomattox, and Wounded Knee: Party Politics and the Road to an American Massacre. [1, 2]

We are in a constitutional crisis and we cannot get along with the people who are causing that crisis. It's like the firefighters getting along with the arsonist. It doesn't work that way.
9秒钟
I'm Martin Wolf, chief economics commentator at the Financial Times.
14秒钟
American voters have delivered a resounding defeat to Donald Trump's Republicans. The Democrats [music] now control both the House of
22秒钟
Representatives and the Senate, but Trump still has two years in the White House. How much can the Democrats
29秒钟
constrain him? And has this election changed the course of American democracy?
41秒钟
The Democrats have won big in the US midterms after voters delivered a sharp rebuke to President Trump and the
49秒钟
Republican party. But how unprecedented is this landslide and how important will it prove in the long term? In my final
58秒钟
podcast in this series, which have been looking at the midterms, I'm joined by someone who can help me understand how
1分钟6秒钟
these elections fit into the broader 250ear sweep of US political history.
1分钟13秒钟
Heather Cox Richardson is a professor of history at Boston College and author of the popular Substack newsletter, Letters
1分钟22秒钟
from an American. She knows a thing or two about the political battles that have shaped the United States from the
1分钟30秒钟
Civil War to the present day. Heather, welcome to the show.
1分钟34秒钟
It's a pleasure to be here. So Heather, the day after the midterms, you wrote that one error in American politics was
1分钟42秒钟
ending and another beginning. What did you mean by that?
1分钟46秒钟
I think the midterm verdict on mega republicanism is broader than simply being about Trump or being about the
1分钟54秒钟
MAGA Republicans. That it is a rejection of the economic vision of the Republican party since the 1980s. And I I'm making
2分钟4秒钟
that argument not just because of the fact it was Republicans who were swept out so profoundly in some key demographics, but also because many of
2分钟13秒钟
the issues surrounding the election were not simply the corruption of the Trump administration. Although that appears to have been item number one across a
2分钟22秒钟
number of demographics, but that if you look at the people who turned against Trump, not only where they live, including rural areas, they are looking
2分钟30秒钟
at really big issues that change the nature of uh American politics. So, one of the key issues in that election was
2分钟39秒钟
data centers. Those data centers seem to me to be a symbol of the recognition that the American political and economic
2分钟48秒钟
system has been rigged in favor of the very wealthy now for a very long time.
2分钟53秒钟
And Americans have woken up to it. And when that happens, as it has happened in our past in the 1920s to the 1930s, the
3分钟
1890s, and the 1850s, you see a dramatic change in American politics. So that's what I was looking at when I said that.
3分钟7秒钟
So you're really describing a major turning point. You've described US political history as a struggle, a long
3分钟14秒钟
struggle between democracy and oligarchy. Can you explain your thinking here and illustrate a bit, you've
3分钟22秒钟
already touched upon it, how this played out over the last 250 years and why you
3分钟29秒钟
think we might be at the beginning of a new, I suppose, one might say progressive cycle. We tend to have
3分钟36秒钟
periods in which the majority of voters recognize that the system has been rigged, like I just said, in such a way
3分钟43秒钟
that it's privileging men usually, usually white men of wealth and power who are working handin glove with the
3分钟50秒钟
government in order to uh skew the entire system in their favor. When that happens, there tends to be a rebellion against it that changes our political
3分钟59秒钟
system. and we get a slew of legislation that creates a fairer economy that spreads the ability to prosper more
4分钟8秒钟
widely than it had been under the previous regime. Now again, because of our peculiar history, and by peculiar I don't just mean odd. I mean sort of
4分钟16秒钟
especially um focused in the American system. It is possible for those people who want to concentrate wealth to turn
4分钟24秒钟
to this government that is working more broadly for the American people and claim that that system is a socialist
4分钟32秒钟
system. They start to argue that the kinds of government that work for all Americans as opposed to just a a
4分钟39秒钟
privileged few will mean the redistribution of tax dollars from the wealthy to undeserving populations,
4分钟47秒钟
minority populations in terms of race or ethnicity or women or some category that can be described as other. And when they
4分钟55秒钟
do that, they tend to divide the American voting population, rise to power yet again. And then often there is a dramatic economic crash and the cycle
5分钟4秒钟
starts all over again. That pattern has been throughout our history since at least the 1850s to say the 1890s, the
5分钟11秒钟
1930s. But if you think back to the principles of the framers of the constitution and the founders of the
5分钟20秒钟
what became the American nation, their concern was always that a system that is designed to uh govern a body of people
5分钟29秒钟
always tends to concentrate power among a very small group. And if you think about that and you think about the way they framed it and the checks and
5分钟38秒钟
balances they put in our system to prevent that from happening, I think you can make an argument that the meaning of American democracy is the attempt to
5分钟45秒钟
prevent the concentration of wealth and power in a government.
5分钟49秒钟
Let's just think go through some of the big swings that have occurred in the past. One of the periods you emphasize
5分钟58秒钟
is the 1850s which saw um well among other things as I understand it the birth of the
6分钟7秒钟
Republican party itself and was a precursor of the civil war and of course it produced one of the great heroes of
6分钟15秒钟
global democracy not just uh uh American democracy Abraham Lincoln. So tell us a
6分钟22秒钟
bit about that moment of rebirth or birth as it were of a more democratic
6分钟29秒钟
and inclusive idea in this case obviously ended up with a war over slavery and how relevant that might be to where we are now.
6分钟39秒钟
So I'm particularly fond of the 1850s for a number of reasons and there is a political pattern embedded in them that
6分钟47秒钟
is very much on my mind in this present moment. You had two aged political parties that were not grappling with the
6分钟56秒钟
elephant in the room, which was the rise of what people in the north especially called the slave power. And by that they
7分钟3秒钟
meant the elite southern enslavers who had taken over the Democratic party. And by taking over the Democratic party had
7分钟11秒钟
also taken over the Supreme Court, the Senate, and the presidency, which should sound somewhat familiar, right? If you
7分钟18秒钟
were a northerner in 1854, you could look at that and you could say, "Well, I really don't care. I am interested
7分钟25秒钟
primarily in moving to the city or moving west and we're in this economic boom and and I'm really interested more in my bottom line than I am in what's
7分钟33秒钟
happening in Washington. It doesn't matter to me." And it doesn't have to matter to me because we have the House of Representatives. There's so many more of us in this country. We control the
7分钟43秒钟
House of Representatives and those elite southern enslavers are less than 1% of the population. And so how bad can they really be? How bad can it really be? And
7分钟51秒钟
then in 1854, you get pressure from the president especially, but also from the Senate on the members of the House of
7分钟58秒钟
Representatives to push through a law called the Kansas Nebraska Act. And that act overturned the 1820 Missouri Compromise, which had said that
8分钟7秒钟
enslavement would not spread west into a lot of the territory there. With the overturning of the Missouri Compromise,
8分钟14秒钟
if enslavers move their slave property into those western territories, they will become western states. And those western states will work with the
8分钟23秒钟
southern slave states in order to make enslavement national to overall the vast majority of Americans who live in the
8分钟30秒钟
north and make the country a nation of slavery. When that happens, literally the the day after, there's a meeting in
8分钟38秒钟
Washington of about 30 congressmen and they come into that room and they say to each other, "Listen, we don't agree about internal improvements and we don't
8分钟45秒钟
agree about financing and we don't agree about immigration, but by God, we can agree that we do not want to lose our
8分钟52秒钟
democracy to the slave power." And over the course of 54, 55, and 56, those
9分钟
anti-N Nebraska people sweep the state elections in the the American North.
9分钟6秒钟
They get into Congress and they they get into positions of power at the state and they start to talk about what American democracy should look like. And over the
9分钟15秒钟
course of the the 1850s, as the slave power digs in, they beat a senator from Massachusetts almost to death on the
9分钟24秒钟
floor of the Senate, for example, you start to see the rise of Abraham Lincoln in Illinois, who listens to all these
9分钟31秒钟
different people and he begins to articulate not just a position against human enslavement, but also a new vision
9分钟38秒钟
for what American democracy should be, of the people, by the people, for the people, Right. And he starts to advocate a number of positions that will enable
9分钟48秒钟
ordinary people, ordinary men to obtain property, to work hard, and to rise. And that becomes the driving ideology of the
9分钟57秒钟
Republican party. So when I look at the chaos we're in now, the MAGA Republicans jumping off a cliff, which itself is really interesting, but everybody else
10分钟5秒钟
is left back on the the clifftop saying we don't actually know what we stand for. All we know is we don't stand for
10分钟12秒钟
that. What I see is the 1850s and new ideas of people saying what does democracy look like in the 21st century?
10分钟19秒钟
What should we do? What should the government do? What what are its obligations? What are its duties? And those are um really reflective, I think, of a similar period in the 1850s.
10分钟30秒钟
That's a very interesting parallel.
10分钟32秒钟
Let's just talk about where we are now after this remarkable result and dig into your view that it's a fundamental transformation.
10分钟42秒钟
Isn't it possible that actually it was a backlash against Trump and his policies
10分钟49秒钟
which were so egregious, the corruption, the brutality, it's not a deeper repudiation of the whole agenda of the
10分钟58秒钟
Republican party of the last uh 60 years or so. You think I think that it's the latter. So would you explain why?
11分钟5秒钟
Yes, of course. I'm a prophet of the past, not the future. Anything is possible, right? It could it could simply all be erased tomorrow. That is
11分钟12秒钟
not my impression of what's happening for a number of reasons. First of all, one of the things we don't talk enough about is we have a big demographic
11分钟19秒钟
change going on right now in the United States with the passing of the baby boomers, of whom I have am one, into a new generation. And one of the things
11分钟27秒钟
that really jumps out about Texas going so dramatically blue is that Texas is one of the youngest states in the union
11分钟34秒钟
demographically. And that demographic change, I think, is a very, very important one. Obviously, that's not going anywhere, first of all. So, then
11分钟43秒钟
there is also the fact that the list you just made of things that are happening in the Trump administration are not
11分钟50秒钟
unique to the Trump administration. They are exacerbated in the Trump administration, but they are not unique to it. So tax cuts, for example, the
11分钟58秒钟
cutting of social services and so on, right back to, as you and I were talking about 1981 when you first get the rise
12分钟5秒钟
of Ronald Reagan and the idea of neoliberalism or supply side economics going into the system. Well, one of the
12分钟12秒钟
things that we have seen a lot, especially in the last two years, is the rise of popular economists explaining that to people and the rise of
12分钟20秒钟
politicians talking a lot about how the billionaires have everything. And one of the things that has made that especially
12分钟28秒钟
salient here again, especially since Trump 2.0 is Elon Musk. I mean, Elon Musk is the poster child for the the bad
12分钟37秒钟
acting Robert Baron, right? That combined with the data centers that have sprung up like mushrooms and people hate
12分钟45秒钟
them on a bipartisan basis. I think again a symbol of the loss of control over our public spaces to these people
12分钟53秒钟
has created something that I do not think is just I'm not happy with the cost of eggs. I think it's a recognition
12分钟59秒钟
that the system has to change. And you know when you look at the calls that people are making, yes they're mad at Trump, but they're not just mad at
13分钟6秒钟
Trump. They want health care, which does not seem to be like a radical idea in
13分钟14秒钟
2026, especially when we're one of the few countries that doesn't have such a program. You know, they want decent salaries. Again, you know, being able to
13分钟22秒钟
work a 40-hour week and be able to pay rent. I mean, the things that people want are not a different flavor of some
13分钟30秒钟
sort of liberal democracy. It is the reinstitution of liberal democracy. And I don't see putting that genie back in the bottle. My concern is actually the
13分钟38秒钟
opposite. That you may end up as the as MAGA doubles down, which it is doing right now, you may end up with the
13分钟46秒钟
opposite. People saying, well, you know, forget it. We don't want uh liberal democracy at all. We're happy to try something else. And that I think is
13分钟55秒钟
reminiscent of where FDR found himself in 1933. So that's really an important issue and it fits with my concerns in
14分钟3秒钟
recent years about the possibility that we lose democracy altogether. Um but
14分钟10秒钟
before I get that um suddenly the de the Democrats find themselves with an immensely powerful position in Congress.
14分钟18秒钟
They can to significant extent express a new ideology of government which I don't think they really have done so far. It's
14分钟27秒钟
quite a confusing picture to me. So, what do you think the Democrats need to do? How do they need to behave to cement
14分钟37秒钟
this new and obviously in some respects fractious electoral coalition?
14分钟42秒钟
Well, just to be clear, I think the confusion is a good thing right now.
14分钟45秒钟
People say to me a lot, who are you behind for 2028 and who is leading and why is nobody speaking? And my answer to
14分钟52秒钟
that comes from the 1850s. We look at the emergence of Abraham Lincoln, but he was one of about 10 people who were speaking at that point for a new kind of
15分钟1秒钟
politics. And he managed to absorb what at least if not were the best of those things, they were the enduring things
15分钟8秒钟
that a majority of northerners could get behind. And I think we're seeing the exact same thing. You can watch it if you look closely enough. You can watch
15分钟15秒钟
some of the the leaders of the Democratic or non- mega Republicans starting to send up trial balloons and
15分钟23秒钟
you can see new voices coming up saying new things and if you they don't get a good response, they back off of them or they push further in one direction or
15分钟32秒钟
another. It's actually a really interesting dance to be watching. So, so that doesn't worry me. What the Democrats need to do going forward, I think, is not rocket science, right?
15分钟42秒钟
They are not in control of the White House. And the person in control of the White House is famously erratic at best.
15分钟49秒钟
Those of us who are watching him closely do not think that he is either mentally or physically healthy. And it's not clear who's calling the shots in the
15分钟58秒钟
White House. What is clear is that those shots have been at least controversial enough and possibly illegal enough that
16分钟7秒钟
the White House is now madly trying to cover its tracks and make sure it can't have investigations. And that does not
16分钟14秒钟
speak well for the next two years. That being said, the Congress has to do a couple of things. It has to investigate the lawb breakaking. And those
16分钟22秒钟
investigations, by the way, are about returning the rule of law, but they're also about informing the American people of what has been done on their watch and
16分钟29秒钟
what is legal and what needs to be changed. This is really about democracy.
16分钟34秒钟
It's not just about saying it's wildly out of realm to be bombing small boats
16分钟42秒钟
in the Caribbean, in the Eastern Pacific, right? That's not just about that, although that's the heart of it.
16分钟47秒钟
It's about everything that goes around it. So, they have to do that. And they also, I think, need to take on specific pieces of legislation, not these big
16分钟56秒钟
omnibus bills that throw everything, including the kitchen sink, into a 2600page bill because it's the only thing that will pass through Congress.
17分钟4秒钟
They need to put really popular things into small individual bills like extending the supplemental nutrition
17分钟13秒钟
assistance program benefits so that people can I don't know eat you know things that are very specific but have immediate meaningful changes in people's
17分钟22秒钟
lives and you know it's entirely possible that Trump or JD Vance if he is in the White House will veto those things but making a clear difference
17分钟31秒钟
between what is wildly popular these position that I just laid out are not fringe popularity. These are things the
17分钟38秒钟
American people want and what mega Republicans are offering is going to be crucial going forward. and the fact that
17分钟45秒钟
the White House is not only doubling down on what the American people has just rejected, but adding more emphasis
17分钟54秒钟
to it. you know, the removal of Susie Wilds as White House chief of staff and her replacement by Steven Miller, who's been the architect of the deportation
18分钟2秒钟
programs that the American people just utterly rejected is making the Democrats job a lot easier because had the White
18分钟11秒钟
House moderated, they might have been able to say, "Well, listen, we we really did hear you and we're really doing what you want." And in fact, the White House
18分钟18秒钟
is taking the opposite position. So, I expect we're going to see more concentration around what the American people want in the next two years. But
18分钟27秒钟
make no mistake, it's going to be incredibly rough and incredibly rocky because you have Trump cornered. You
18分钟34秒钟
have him really able to move most freely in foreign policy. It's going to be a rocky couple of years.
18分钟41秒钟
Seems clear. We saw Donald Trump in a sort of kissy kissy with uh Vladimir Putin and Xiingping which is not
18分钟50秒钟
something one would have expected of an American president until relatively recently. So we are certainly seeing what looks the beginning of a very
18分钟57秒钟
uncomfortable world in in foreign relations. You've already mentioned that the Democrats should use their investigative powers which will itself
19分钟5秒钟
obviously create quite clearly from the reasons you said lots of friction with the White House which will be uh quite
19分钟14秒钟
something. Another area where I think the possibility of major blowups occur, I wonder if you thought about budgets,
19分钟22秒钟
the budgetary power, which Congress clearly has, the possibility of of another debt sealing crisis,
19分钟31秒钟
possibly closure. These are real instruments that Congress possesses and therefore the Democratic Party uh
19分钟38秒钟
possesses. How far do you expect the Democrats and how far in your view should the Democrats use these to um
19分钟48秒钟
assert their will because they in these areas they clearly have in principle enormous powers.
19分钟55秒钟
So uh to be clear those are two separate things.
19分钟58秒钟
Of course the budgeting for this year it runs out on December 11th which is still when the Republicans control both the House and
20分钟7秒钟
the Senate. My guess is the Congress will continue to fund the government as it is at the previous levels, which is
20分钟14秒钟
what essentially hitting a snooze button going forward to toss the problem into the new Congress. Not least because a lot of people who have lost election
20分钟22秒钟
aren't even showing up to to to Washington, which is just mind-boggling to me. control over things like the
20分钟32秒钟
extraordinary amount of money the Republicans gave to uh Customs and Border Protection, which is the parent agency for border patrol, which are
20分钟40秒钟
those agents who have been on the streets doing things like shooting um Alex Prey, and the money that they gave as part of that to immigration and
20分钟49秒钟
customs enforcement or ICE. I would be stunned if those huge pots of money don't come in some fashion to be clawed
20分钟57秒钟
back because those are actually funding those institutions, those agencies through the end of Trump's term. That's why they got so much money. And of
21分钟5秒钟
course, those things are wildly unpopular. That's one of the things that voters made clear they didn't like in in
21分钟12秒钟
November. But but then there is the question of the debt ceiling, and I would love to hear what you have to say about that. It's a weird system and it came from actually World War I. One of
21分钟21秒钟
the things that a number of Democrats have talked about and that Trump has indicated he likes as well for very different reasons is simply to get rid
21分钟29秒钟
of the debt ceiling altogether. That does not take care of the problem of the debt which at this point is over $40 trillion and climbing. So I don't know
21分钟38秒钟
how that's going to play out but I do know it is not only a political problem.
21分钟44秒钟
This is an existential crisis to the American economy, to the American government, and I would suggest to the
21分钟52秒钟
world economy as well. And the fact it's a political football horrifies me. What do you think about it? Well, it's an incredibly stupid idea.
21分钟59秒钟
I've written about this quite often, but given that it's there, and as I understand, I've been looking into it.
22分钟5秒钟
It the ceiling is likely to be hit sort of in the next financial year, then it's
22分钟12秒钟
a lever. But of course, like all these things, it's the sort of thing that can blow up in your face to mix metaphors.
22分钟18秒钟
And it's one of the issues that the Democrats will have to confront because they are in a position to impose very considerable constraints in principle on
22分钟28秒钟
this administration. Some of them could be incredibly dangerous and cause very significant crises. And this is the most
22分钟35秒钟
obvious one. The fundamental question here is how far do you think it makes sense in this situation for the
22分钟42秒钟
Democrats to play real hard ball with the administration because God knows there are enough and issues to do so.
22分钟51秒钟
And how much do you think it makes sense if you take the whole political context to try and work out a motus for Vendi
22分钟58秒钟
which doesn't blow things up because there's some very difficult judgments to be made here particularly given the power that they have in certain important respects.
23分钟8秒钟
So I'll start by answering that with the observation that I'm in the cheap seats.
23分钟12秒钟
Like it's very easy to sit here behind my laptop and say well they should do this and they shouldn't do this. and I am always aware of that and giving the
23分钟20秒钟
people in those real seats grace. That being said, one of the things that concerns me is the degree to which a
23分钟29秒钟
number of holdover people in the government still think we're doing business as usual. And one of the things
23分钟35秒钟
about the Trump administration 2.0 that is unique is that they have not simply operated illegally and unconstitutionally.
23分钟46秒钟
They have acted as if the constitution doesn't exist. They have not recognized the authority of the courts. They have not recognized the guardrails in the
23分钟55秒钟
constitution and so on. So that being said, aside from the political implications of this, I would argue, and
24分钟2秒钟
I think the political implications are important, that the Democrats need to act as if we are in a constitutional crisis because we have been in one since
24分钟10秒钟
the day Trump took power and refused to acknowledge Congress's authority to appropriate money. That we are in a constitutional crisis and we cannot get
24分钟19秒钟
along with the people who are causing that crisis. It's like the firefighters getting along with the arsonist. It doesn't work that way. But I would also
24分钟26秒钟
add to that that there is a political imperative behind that and that's that the mood of the country has changed to want fighters. And again the same thing was true in the 1850s and the 1890s.
24分钟37秒钟
That's how we get Teddy Roosevelt of course in the 1890s. They want people who are going to stand up against the tech bros for example those people who
24分钟45秒钟
are monopolizing wealth and power in the country. Although just just as a as a rabbit hole here, the tech bros are madly running away from MAGA at this
24分钟52秒钟
point, which is itself interesting, of course.
24分钟55秒钟
But so but so there is that imperative as well to to say that we're going to fight. And then there is also, I think,
25分钟4秒钟
something that tends to get obscured in the myriad articles about the Democrats being divided between the establishment
25分钟12秒钟
and the progressives. In fact, if you actually look at what all the Democrats are calling for, the things that they
25分钟19秒钟
want are what I keep referring to as lowhanging fruit. So, when you look, for example, at the idea of universal health
25分钟26秒钟
care, even Republicans want that. 57% of Republicans want that. So, simply doing
25分钟33秒钟
what many people are interpreting as being extremist is actually a popular thing to do. So,
25分钟41秒钟
I'm going to take the position that the Democrats should go for broke on everything. Now, that being said, one of
25分钟48秒钟
the things you'll see them getting criticized for is uh a number of them, including at this point Senator Elect Abdul Elsad of Michigan have said, you
25分钟57秒钟
know, let's do universal healthcare and call it Trump care. And people are are especially those who are further left than others, saying, how dare you work
26分钟6秒钟
with him. And and I actually think that's really smart, sort of putting it on Trump's desk and saying you can be a hero, you know, it will put your name on
26分钟14秒钟
it. I actually think I don't care what it's called. I want it to happen. And that you probably will see a lot of,
26分钟22秒钟
especially under those people who are politically astute like Zoron Mandani, the mayor of New York, who has worked
26分钟30秒钟
Trump and gotten what he wanted by doing that. And that I think is not a bad approach to use cover in order to get extreme change.
26分钟40秒钟
If the Democrats did this and became more of a if you like a European social democratic party, that will be absolutely fine. In many ways, perfectly
26分钟49秒钟
same. They would have to argue for higher taxes and and and take on the the
26分钟56秒钟
great Republican principle that there must under no circumstance ever be a tax increase. But look at where our taxes
27分钟4秒钟
are compared to any comparable country and look at where they are compared to the history of the United States. We are at an all-time low and money is
27分钟12秒钟
concentrating overwhelmingly at the top of our society. And people are increasingly aware of that. One of the positions that I keep taking and
27分钟20秒钟
pointing out is that you know the party that invented the American income tax.
27分钟25秒钟
Other countries had used something similar but in the United States of America the party that invents the income tax and it was a progressive
27分钟32秒钟
income tax from the beginning is the Republican party. That was a different Republican party.
27分钟38秒钟
It it is a different Republican party, but the Republican party like the American government has gone through a number of iterations and it is not
27分钟47秒钟
unheard of for it to jump into a a different period. And and just to give you an example of that, think of what
27分钟55秒钟
happened in the United States in the 1920s under Treasury Secretary Andrew Melon where he gave so many rebates to
28分钟2秒钟
people that in fact he managed to undercut the idea of progressive taxation after World War I. But we get
28分钟9秒钟
our highest level of income tax uh rates under a Republican president just 20, 30 years later, Dwight Eisenhower went the
28分钟18秒钟
top income tax bracket was 91 to 92%. So it's not impossible and I would say it is absolutely imperative.
28分钟26秒钟
So going to ask you three final questions and uh let's try and make them nice punchy answers because they are
28分钟34秒钟
they require it. The first is is this the end of the MAGA movement? Uh and therefore is it inevitable from what
28分钟43秒钟
we've just seen this repudiation that the Republican party transformation you're talking about will happen because it has to
28分钟51秒钟
not the end of the MAGA movement. Those people will always be in American society. It is the end of the MAGA movement as the driving force in the Republican party and the Republican
29分钟
party like the Democratic party is going to have to reinvent itself.
29分钟3秒钟
That's a very powerful answer. What do these elections mean for the future of oligarchy in America? Is that just an
29分钟12秒钟
endless struggle and they've just really overreached very badly in the last uh few years? Or do you think this actually
29分钟19秒钟
might be sort of long-term transformative?
29分钟24秒钟
Well, that's not a short answer question. No, it isn't. I I I I agree it isn't.
29分钟30秒钟
I do think that we don't know what's going to happen. The people who have a lot of money still have a lot of money and they still exert an unusual amount
29分钟40秒钟
of influence in the United States but there is clearly a political move to reign them in and that will happen
29分钟47秒钟
someday I think but the question is whether it's going to be in the next 3 years or the next 30 years or the next
29分钟54秒钟
300 years. Um final question obviously we focused rightly on the US because it is the most important country in the world and the most important country
30分钟3秒钟
certainly for those who share western liberal values. Um obviously the behavior of the US in this period has
30分钟11秒钟
been an enormous shock. I mentioned the so-called Yelta 2 meeting which is certainly a huge shock uh on multiple
30分钟20秒钟
fronts. um the US has withdrawn from the world but then it's also intervened in it in the most erratic and unpredictable
30分钟29秒钟
way and it seems rather consistently to be supporting well at least some of the tyrants. Do you think that it will
30分钟38秒钟
continue for the next two years and thereafter or can you imagine that we're going to get back something like the US
30分钟47秒钟
as a stabilizing hedgeman in the world which we were so used to and most of us very very much miss. It's pretty clear
30分钟56秒钟
that Trump has adopted Vladimir Putin's view of dividing the world into spheres of influence. And I think that that's a lot of what's behind this tripartite
31分钟5秒钟
meeting that you're talking about taking place in mid November of 2026.
31分钟11秒钟
But it is important to remember as you look at that that Vladimir Putin is weak. You know, for all that he's trying to look like he's one of the kings of
31分钟20秒钟
the world, he is weak right now. His economy is in trouble. the war in Ukraine has is turned against him. What
31分钟27秒钟
is really propping him up right now is Donald Trump. I don't think Trump has been erratic. I think Trump has been operating with the idea that the United
31分钟34秒钟
States is going to control the Western Hemisphere and that's clearly what uh Secretary of State Marco Rubio is on board for. He wants Cuba. We've got this
31分钟42秒钟
invasion into Venezuela taking their oil. The key here is that Trump continues to want to control uh fossil
31分钟51秒钟
fuels around the world and that seems to be the the motivating piece for him in his foreign interventions. Now, is that
31分钟59秒钟
going to last? What I would say is that in the short term, Trump has more leeway in foreign affairs than he has in
32分钟6秒钟
anything else because of the way the Constitution is written. Not fully, by the way. It has not been interpreted that way throughout its entire history.
32分钟14秒钟
but also because of what this current Supreme Court has said in that it keeps saying he has leeway in foreign affairs which is one of the reasons he has
32分钟22秒钟
couched so much of his domestic legislation as being some aspect of foreign affairs like the deportations of
32分钟30秒钟
people coming across our southern border he interpreted as a foreign affairs issue. So he's going to do more not less
32分钟37秒钟
I suspect but the question is going to be is Congress going to fund this stuff?
32分钟41秒钟
I mean, the the military is in trouble in terms of its munitions and in terms of its funding. Are senators going to stand behind this? Are they going to
32分钟50秒钟
stop his war on Iran, for example? So, I would suspect that in the next two years, you're not suddenly going to see the United States changing what Trump
33分钟
wants for it, but I do not expect this to last. Now, one of the things that is most interesting to me in this moment, to be honest, is if you look at what
33分钟9秒钟
Trump has done and what the world was really coming to in the falling apart essentially of the rules-based international order for a number of
33分钟17秒钟
reasons, I have not yet seen a real replacement for it. that is under former President Joe Biden and his Secretary of
33分钟26秒钟
State Anthony Blinken. You saw this terribly named concept of essentially ad hoc committees where different countries
33分钟34秒钟
would get together to talk about fentanyl for example and address the fentanyl crisis or border crossings or whatever was of interest to those
33分钟42秒钟
particular countries based essentially by the way on the European Union. But within that theory, there was never a theory for what you do when you have a
33分钟50秒钟
rogue leader like Putin, like Trump, like Netanyahu. What do you do to make those people behave in ways that are
33分钟58秒钟
sociable, if you will, that are going to enable the countries to work together?
34分钟2秒钟
And so what you're seeing now, I think, is people like Mark Carney out of Canada suggesting something something similar with a crucial difference where Blinken
34分钟10秒钟
and Biden assumed that the United States would be sitting at all of those tables.
34分钟15秒钟
One of the reasons they kept insisting that the United States was a Pacific power as well as an Atlantic power that essentially let them sit at all the tables. People like Carney are saying we
34分钟24秒钟
don't need the big guys. We can do it as a middle group, which is a lovely idea, but it has that same problem. How do you re in the people who are refusing to
34分钟32秒钟
acknowledge, for example, the mission statement of the UN that they can't invade their neighbors? So to me intellectually and in terms of our
34分钟40秒钟
future what's going to happen in foreign affairs is the question not the secondary question the question going
34分钟48秒钟
forward in the 21st century I agree with that completely and it brings us back to the the central premise of this whole series the psycho
34分钟57秒钟
drama if that's the word the political drama of the United States has vast global significance and uh while this is
35分钟5秒钟
an important moment in it. The questions about that remain. Heather Cox Richardson, thank you very much for talking to us today.
35分钟13秒钟
Thank you for having me.
35分钟14秒钟
This brings to an end our series of episodes discussing the state of US politics, its relationship to global politics around the midterms.
35分钟26秒钟
The result of the midterms have been quite astonishing. a a far more radical
35分钟33秒钟
repudiation of the Trump administration, the Republican party and the MAGA movement than we expected. And this is
35分钟42秒钟
obviously immensely encouraging. But it does leave some very big questions about
35分钟49秒钟
the future. First, how will divided government, and it's going to be very divided government in the US going to
35分钟56秒钟
work? How is it actually going to uh going to function? How will the Trump administration itself respond to what
36分钟4秒钟
has happened? Will it take even bigger risks, particularly abroad? And what might that look like? Will the
36分钟11秒钟
institutions of all kinds that have been so badly damaged be able to restore themselves to
36分钟20秒钟
to regain the vitality of the US constitutional system that has been so clearly under
36分钟29秒钟
attack. And then there are the implications for the world as a whole.
36分钟32秒钟
We have relied on the US. It has been the central hegemonic power particularly for the liberal democracies. It has not
36分钟41秒钟
played that role very clearly. Indeed, the role has been repudiated by Donald Trump. Can that be restored and can the
36分钟49秒钟
trust that that was placed in the US be regained? These questions are very much
36分钟57秒钟
still live. We've had a good moment, but the story is most certainly not over.

路过

鸡蛋

鲜花

握手

雷人

评论 (0 个评论)

facelist

您需要登录后才可以评论 登录 | 注册

法律申明|用户条约|隐私声明|小黑屋|联系我们|www.kwcg.ca

GMT-5, 2026-11-22 01:30 , Processed in 0.023292 second(s), 19 queries , Gzip On.

Powered by Discuz! X5.0

© 2001-2021 Comsenz Inc.  

返回顶部